How to evaluate
accounting practice
management software
in two weeks
Shortlist two or three tools, then put the same real work through each one for two weeks. It is written for the owner of a firm with somewhere between 2 and 20 people who needs a decision before the next deadline, not a months-long project. If you have no shortlist yet, start with how seven tools compare on moving in and AI.
Which tests show which practice management software fits your firm?
Four tests on your own data show more than any demo: one each for clients, recurring work, AI and the move.
| Test | How to run it | A pass looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Client | Send a test request to a staff test contact | They finish it in their browser without creating an account |
| Recurring | Set up one monthly and one annual client and let a period roll over | The next job opens on time, already assigned |
| AI | A staff member connects Claude, or ChatGPT on the web with a Business, Enterprise or Edu seat, and updates a task | Their permissions hold and the owner sees the change |
| Move | Bring in a slice of your clients and documents | You check it before anything reaches a client |
In Firmary, the client test runs through PocketFirm, the recurring test through work templates, the AI test through the firm’s agent rules, and the move test through a trial import you check.
What does a two-week evaluation look like?
A two-week evaluation has four short phases: load real data, run real work, test the awkward cases, then decide.
Days 1 to 3, load. Ask each vendor to load a staged test copy of twenty or thirty clients, with their open work and a year of documents, that no client can see.
Days 4 to 8, run. Send one document request, one engagement letter and one invoice to a staff member set up as a test client, using test records only. Close one recurring job and put one return through review.
Days 9 to 12, push on it. The test client uploads last year’s 1099. A preparer is out sick. Someone asks an AI assistant to change a due date. Watch what each tool does.
Days 13 and 14, decide. Score each tool on what you saw, using the checklist at the bottom of this page.
With Firmary, the load phase is the move itself: the clients, work and documents each old tool exposes are staged for you to check, and nothing is sent to a client. When a preparer is out, out of office routes fresh client messages, plus any task falling due, to the colleague covering.
What costs beyond the subscription should you ask about?
Ask every vendor for the full first-year cost in writing: subscription, onboarding, add-ons and any minimum. Those extras can outweigh the gap between two plans. On 10 Nov 2026, TaxDome sold a workflow optimization package for $749,1 Canopy’s self-guided setup cost $199, refunded once six setup milestones were done within 60 days,2 and Karbon’s monthly billing needed a team of four or more.3
When you ask Firmary for a price, ask about the move in the same email; a specialist from Firmary can handle it together with your staff.
What should you ask about AI in practice management software?
Ask what the AI does inside the product, whether staff can bring their own assistant, and who can see what the AI did. A vague answer to the last question is reason enough to cross a tool off.
In Firmary, AI reads W-2s, 1098s, Schedule K-1s (Form 1065) and the common 1099s (INT, DIV and B) and fills in proposed values that a person confirms, writes draft replies that spell out what the client still owes the firm, and suggests the next step on a job. Staff who prefer Claude, or ChatGPT on the web under a Business, Enterprise or Edu subscription, connect it under their own login and access. The owner picks On its own, Asks first or Never in five areas: drafts, notes, client records, sending to clients, and payments and refunds. Owners can review what agents did recently. AI stays optional, and a firm can do everything directly in Firmary.
How do you make the final call between two practice management tools?
Pick the tool your clients and staff used without help during the trial. Feature counts rarely decide it; the number of things someone had to do by hand usually does.
Score each tool against the checklist below and weigh the client test most: a portal clients avoid sends every request back to email. Then ask what leaving would look like, and read the short answers on switching, cost and data before you sign.
Questions to ask in a demo
- Send a document request to my own phone right now, and show me every step I take to answer it.
- Show me next month’s recurring work opening without anyone creating it.
- Set one job to repeat for forty clients at once. How long does that take?
- Connect ChatGPT or Claude as a staff member. What can it change?
- Where does the owner see what an AI agent did yesterday?
- Can we make an agent ask before it changes a record?
- What does AI do inside the product, and who confirms it?
- What happens to a preparer’s clients when that person is out?
- How does a website inquiry become a client with a signed engagement letter?
- Can we see our own clients and documents in the tool before we switch?
- Who does the move, and what does it cost?
A checklist to print
- A test contact finished a request in a phone browser, no account
- Next month’s work opened by itself, already assigned
- Each person had a daily list without building one
- A staff member used their own AI assistant
- The owner could set AI rules and review recent agent actions
- AI proposed values, a person confirmed them
- Prospect, proposal and invoice sat on one client record
- Our own data was checked before we switched
- We checked which documents came across
- First-year cost known in writing, onboarding included
Request access to Firmary
Leave your work email and we’ll email you the next step.
Sources
Each product fact on this page links to a numbered source. Quotes are copied as the page’s text reads on the date shown, spacing included.
- 1
TaxDome
Workflow optimization | $749 | Optimize workflows with three dedicated 1:1 sessions with automation specialists. ... Account management package—12 months | $1,788/12 months | ... Workflow optimization is included at no extra cost.
- 2
Canopy
Self-guided implementation costs $199 dollars. You receive a full refund when you complete six setup milestones within 60 days.
- 3
Karbon
Monthly billing for 4+ users.